Hebdomadaire et mensuel TF trading - Wow Quelque chose me déconcerte. Une année est composée de 12 mois. Un mois est composé d'une semaine. Une semaine est faite pour 7 jours. Une journée est composée de 24 heures. Une heure est faite de 60 minutes. Une minute est composée de 60 secondes. Cela étant dit, comment pouvez-vous le commerce un cadre de temps sans les négocier tous Arent cadres de temps comme un zoom sur un appareil photo Zoom in pour voir les minutes et zoom arrière pour voir le jour, semaines, mois Semble comme une question de combien de temps vous Voulez dans votre image. Quel que soit le graphique que vous regardez quand vous entrez, le marché va faire. Ils feront les mêmes mouvements. La différence, cependant, est que votre position et les attentes est différente selon le calendrier que vous êtes quotusingqu'est la cible d'une configuration commerciale de 5 min est susceptible d'être différente de la cible à partir d'une configuration de commerce hebdomadaire. Antonioforex êtes-vous votre gardien de frères, faites-vous le commerce pour vous-même et une autre personne sur des délais différents je vais répéter le délai que vous faites le plus d'argent sur votre meilleur délai, vous pouvez tordre et tourner tout ce que vous voulez encore rester que le calendrier Vous, vous, (pas quelqu'un d'autre) faire le plus d'argent sur sont votre meilleur timeframe. I suppose que l'anglais est vraiment la langue la plus difficile à comprendre. vous fait 300 pips sur votre calendrier, l'autre personne a fait 800 pips sur leur calendrier. Quelle est la grande affaire avez-vous l'autre personne de négociation. Ce que Antonioforex a essayé de faire était de clarifier les réponses aux commentaires des traders sur le marché faisant le même mouvement sur tous les tableaux. Et c'était une réponse parfaitement appropriée. Peut-être plus de 3 jours le marché ne monter à la fois un quotidien et un plus petit tableau de temps, mais pendant ces 3 jours quelqu'un de négociation le plus petit calendrier (et donc des mouvements plus petits) peut faire beaucoup plus, parce que le marché ne monte pas une ligne droite. Vous devriez sûrement savoir cela. Peut-être avez-vous mal interprété à qui la réponse a été dirigée. Ou peut-être l'anglais est vraiment la langue la plus difficile à comprendre Indépendamment, ce n'était certainement pas la réponse la plus stupide. Forex Com Commentaires et évaluations anomymous Il ya 9 ans SCAM Bonjour les gens. Bienvenue dans le monde de FRAUDEX, qui est au moins comment vous vous sentirez une fois que vous avez été avec Gain Capital. Même que Tradestation Forex Broker - BEWARE. Vous avez une position sur, les nouvelles se produisent, vous sortez et ils prétendent que vous êtes sorti trop vite. Cause they039ll aller après un arrêt qui isn039t même là-bas - aka stop huntingfishing - et vous visser BIG TIME chaque fois que vous sortez avec un bénéfice, they039ll get vous à nouveau avec des excuses similaires. ABSOLUMENT INCOMPETENT. I039m si dissapointed et dégoûté je me sens comme abandonner sur Trading Forex. Ma question est maintenant. Puisque l'abus des clients est si répandu parmi ces courtiers forex, quand l'enfer le gouvernement va ET RÉGLEMENTER CES CRIMINELS. CAUSEQU'ILS SONT. LE COMMERCE DE THEY039LL CONTRE LEURS CLIENTS ET NOONE FAIT UNE CHOSE À SON SUJET. AINSI LES ABUS SE CONTINUERONT TANT QUE LE (S) GOUVERNEMENT (S) DON039T FAIRE UNE CHOSE À SON SUJET. SEJOUR, CAVEAT EMPTOR. VOUS PERDEREZ LA MAJORITE SI NON TOUT VOTRE MONEY COMME BEAUCOUP AVEZ - SI VOUS DON039T CROYEZ-MOI VÉRIFIEZ D'AUTRES SITES WEB DE FOREX RATING COMME WELL-PEACE rob il ya 9 ans SCAM Évitez Forex. Ne jamais ouvrir un compte avec eux, ne jamais envoyer d'argent. Si vous l'avez fait fermer le compte et se déplacer ailleurs. J'avais un début infernal avec eux. J'avais de mauvais sentiments, mais je pensais. Ce qui est le diable. Les gens leur confient des millions de dollars. Ils ne m'auraient pas escroqué de mille 1000 dont j'ai eu l'intention d'ouvrir mon compte. Quand j'ai rempli la demande et envoyé à eux, on m'a demandé de leur fournir deux pièces d'identité, une de vérification Id et une pour le lieu de vie. Je suis Canadien. Je leur ai envoyé la carte de citoyenneté canadienne et l'adresse du chauffeur. J'ai aussi été poussé à envoyer de l'argent avant même que le compte soit ouvert (pour accélérer le processus). Alors je l'ai fait. Alors je reçois la réponse que le liocense du conducteur est O. K. Mais ma carte de citoyenneté canadienne n'est PAS BIEN en tant que document d'identité, car il n'a pas. DATE D'EXPIRATION. (Comme la citoyenneté est quelque chose date d'expiration devrait être mis sur)). J'ai donc envoyé ma carte de santé délivrée par le gouvernement, contenant mon adresse et ma date d'expiration. Pas bien. Cela fait près d'un mois que j'ai commencé le processus de candidature. Ils ont demandé des factures de services publics ou d'autres correspondances. Citant certaines LOIS SUR L'INSÉCURITÉ DOMICILE ou certaines autres RÈGLES NAZI GESTAPO. Je me sentais interrogé comme un criminel ou un suspect de la terreur. Je suis allé à une autre entreprise, qui est de bonne réputation. Ils ont ouvert le acxcount avec seulement la licence de conducteur039s. Aucune question posée dans 1 jour. J'ai décidé de ne pas déranger plus avec Forex. J'ai appelé l'entreprise et demandé mon argent. La dame du service à la clientèle a commencé en premier à faire la vente de tonneau pour me décourager de retirer l'argent. J'ai dit non. J'ai dit que je voulais mon argent, elle promis de les câbler immédiatement. Elle m'a dit aussi qu'elle n'a pas besoin d'instructions de câblage, car elle sait d'où l'argent est venu. Après quelques jours, je l'ai appelée pour me renseigner sur le statut du virement bancaire. Elle a dit qu'elle n'a pas câblé l'argent parce que je devais leur envoyer un formulaire de demande de câble avec la signature. C'est ce que j'ai fait. Attendu encore 10 jours. L'argent n'est pas venu à mon compte. J'ai appelé la dame à nouveau. Elle me dit qu'ils ne peuvent pas se conformer à la demande parce que je don039t ont compte avec eux. Me lançant à nouveau pour ouvrir le compte. J'ai refusé. Alors elle m'a dit que alors je dois aller à ma banque et faire un quotRECALLquot de l'argent. C'est ce que j'ai fait la semaine dernière. Il y a plus de 5 jours. Aujourd'hui, j'ai vérifié dans ma banque. L'argent n'est toujours pas là. La banque va retracer ce qui est arrivé à l'argent. J'attends. De plus en plus impatient. DON039t TROUVER AVEC FOREX. Ils sont escrocs et escrocs. Ils vous escroqueront dès le début et vous remplirez comme un crp après que vous obtenez scked dans leur jeu. R forex questrade Il ya 8 ans SCAM Forex questrade Canada escroquerie Jeudi soir, le 4 sept j'ai été court gbpjpy et est entré un annule l'autre stop loss et limite d'ordre. Le marché se déplaçait très rapidement et a fini de rester toute la nuit faire un bon argent. Je suis restée courte mais quand le vendredi matin est venu et la tendance a inversé avant que je puisse sortir je pensais que je supprimerais la perte d'arrêt parce que je croyais que le marché allait court encore dans les semaines suivantes. Je suis allé à la fenêtre de gestionnaire de positions et ai essayé d'annuler mais le bouton d'annulation ne fonctionnerait pas ainsi j'ai frappé le bouton de modification et ai modifié la position pour lire la perte d'arrêt de zéro et la limite zéro. Je suis ensuite allé à ma page rapports afin que je puisse copier les informations et de vérifier qu'il avait passé mais je ne pouvais pas obtenir des rapports de travailler sur mon système. J'ai pensé que c'était ma faute d'ordinateurs donc j'ai redémarré mon ordinateur et re-démarré la plate-forme de négociation. Je n'étais toujours pas en mesure d'accéder aux rapports. Je suis allé voir si je devais mettre à jour java car il s'agit d'une plate-forme java, mais il a été mis à jour déjà. À cette époque, il était presque 3 Mountain Time et questrade serait fermé et ils sont très difficiles à obtenir une prise de toute façon et je devais me préparer pour le travail. J'ai vérifié de nouveau pour voir si j'avais annulé la perte d'arrêt et sur ma plate-forme il a dit que j'avais et tous les nombres étaient à zéro donc je pensais que je n'avais rien à m'inquiéter. Aussi ma femme était là avec moi toute la journée et a été témoin de tout ce que j'avais fait. Le dimanche quand j'ai ouvert ma plate-forme, je n'avais pas de positions ouvertes et j'ai encore pensé que c'était mon ordinateur glitching donc je l'ai redémarré quelques fois pour voir si mes positions apparaîtraient. En vain, j'ai téléphoné forex la société mère qui possède questrade et leur a dit de la situation. L'homme là a dit qu'il ne voyait aucune raison pour laquelle mes positions étaient fermées car il n'a pas vu une perte d'arrêt entré et il n'y avait aucune raison pour un appel de marge, mais il a dit que je devrais attendre jusqu'à lundi pour parler à questrade comme ils étaient Ceux qui ont fermé mes positions. Le lundi j'ai parlé avec Paul le directeur qui est toujours grossier et arrogant avec moi et a dit si j'avais un plus grand compte et négocié plus alors tout le monde serait heureux et cela n'arrivera jamais. Il a alors dit que je ne trouverais jamais la preuve de ce que je disais et qu'ils allaient coller avec les résultats de la perte d'arrêt et ne pas me compenser de toute façon comme je ne pourrais jamais prouver n'importe quoi que je disais. Je les ai accusés de manipuler ma plate-forme de négociation et d'effacer toutes les empreintes électroniques et de me fermer de mes rapports donc je ne pouvais pas vérifier que j'ai annulé la perte stop. Il a dit qu'il n'a pas pris soin parce que je ne pourrais jamais le prouver. S'il vous plaît aidez-moi à traiter avec cette société et ce problème. Quelqu'un a eu des problèmes avec ces gars. Parfois juste avant de grandes annonces de nouvelles ou avant ou pendant les grands mouvements du marché, je ne serai pas en mesure d'obtenir sur ma plateforme de négociation. Ils ont des heures d'appel très limitées et sont très difficiles à atteindre, mais quand je fais passer à travers ils diront qu'aucun système n'est parfait et qu'il ya des moments où il ya des pépins et that0ss juste une partie du risque de commerce et rien qu'ils peuvent faire Ou fera à ce sujet. J'ai obtenu la même réponse de fxcm quand ils font la même chose, mais finalement, ils me remboursé pour certaines pertes et a admis que c'était leur faute de la plate-forme ne fonctionnait pas, mais il ne compense vraiment tout le stress et les métiers manqués et énormes pertes subies, de cela. Y at-il des courtiers qui ne font pas cela. Qui ne rendent pas impossible d'obtenir sur la plate-forme de commerce ou même de les obtenir par téléphone. s'il vous plaît, faites-moi savoir. Aussi être conscient de cela. Si vous avez un appel de marge qu'ils vont laisser le commerce vont bien au-delà de la marge requise et même si it039s plus que vous avez dans le compte, ils exigent que vous payez le dept. Dans leur livre de la main il indique clairement qu'un commerçant ne peut jamais perdre plus qu'ils investissent. Dans des situations réelles, bien qu'il puisse arriver et ils diront que le marché se déplace rapidement et that039s le meilleur prix qu'ils pourraient obtenir. J'ai lutté contre ce bien et après de nombreux combats sur le téléphone a finalement gagné un peu et n'a pas à payer le montant au-delà de mon solde de compte, mais je n'ai jamais obtenu le montant nécessaire pour la marge. Alors s'il vous plaît prenez garde que vous pouvez perdre plus de whets dans votre compte et certainement chaque centime de votre compte. Soyez conscient que certaines entreprises ont un accès complet à votre plateforme de trading 24 heures par jour, que vous soyez sur ou non. Questrade a et connaît le mot de passe de tout le monde à leurs plates-formes. Certaines entreprises ne le permettent pas parce qu'ils ne peuvent pas réglementer et être responsables de tout courtier ou ouvrier. Mais questrade a trouvé un moyen d'effacer toutes les empreintes électroniques de toute chose au moins that0s ce qui est impliqué par ce qu'ils disent et font. Alors soyez très prudent de la société que vous traitez. Ils ont tout le pouvoir de manipuler n'importe quoi et de s'en tirer avec légalement. Questrade a tout le mot de passe de connaissances donc soyez prudent sal il ya 8 ans plateforme buggy, mais dans l'ensemble, ils ne sont pas mauvais, toujours rempli les commandes comme prévu, très bon service client. Je ne sais pas ce que tous ces gens parlent, je les ai trouvés pour être très bien. Ma plainte principale est que leurs fenêtres plate-forme de négociation basée est médiocre au mieux. Kyle Il ya 8 ans Gardez à l'esprit que 95 des commerçants de détail Forex perdent parce qu'ils don039t ont le plus petit indice de ce qu'ils font. Ils essaient de jouer au tennis contre les joueurs de tennis pro et ne peuvent pas comprendre pourquoi ils perdent leur argent. Regarde, Gain n'est pas celui qui prend ton argent, c'est moi. I039m l'un des 5 qui ont passé des années à étudier et vous êtes l'un des 95 qui se sont surendettés, ont fait tourner la roue et dit quotblackquot. Devinez quels joueurs, vous avez perdu. Chaque transaction nécessite une contrepartie et 99 du temps que la contrepartie n'est pas le courtier, mais d'autres commerçants. Je déteste ces sites de révision parce qu'ils sont dominés par les commerçants perdants pleurer quotIt039s une escroquerie, quotThey m'ont arrêté outquot. Oui, cette industrie trillion dollar entière est une conspiration pour vous frapper hors de votre position délicate 10.000. Essayez d'utiliser moins de levier, de déplacer votre stop loss à une position raisonnable et significative et ils ne peuvent vous arrêter. Si vous obtenez arrêté par le courtier, cela signifie que vous avez pris une très mauvaise position. Les joueurs perdent, vous aussi, arrêtez de pleurnicher .. Alex 8 ans SCAM Forex société a volé mon argent J'étais un client de la société Forex. Un jour, j'ai obtenu un bénéfice sur le commerce de devises. J'ai pris mon profit et j'étais heureux avec cela. Mais après 2 minutes tout mon profit a disparu et une très grande perte est apparue. D'abord je n'ai pas compris comment cela peut arriver. J'ai pensé que c'était une erreur de logiciel et j'ai redémarré ma plateforme de trading. Rien ne change. Ensuite, j'ai vérifié mon historique de négociation pour voir ce qui s'est passé. Et j'ai trouvé trois fausses affaires. Je n'ai pas fait ces affaires inutiles. J'ai essayé de demander au représentant du Forex pourquoi ils ont mis trois fausses affaires sur mon compte. Mais il ne voulait pas me parler. Donc, la société Forex a volé tant d'argent de mon compte. Steve aux États-Unis il y a 8 ans, je négocie des contrats à terme depuis longtemps et j'ai décidé d'essayer le Forex. J'ai fait 3800 la première semaine et 700 la semaine dernière, même si c'était une semaine de vacances. Quand le marché a fermé à 5 heures du matin. Vendredi soir, je me suis écarté pour sortir la poubelle. Lorsque je suis rentré, j'ai été choqué de découvrir que j'étais rempli de mon stop-loss et stop loss plus les ordres de renversement de plus de 85 pips en dessous de la clôture bid-ask spread sur deux devises. Cela m'a mis à une perte de 1400 depuis que j'étais il ya quatre minutes j'ai contacté trois différents ministères par courriel à ce sujet, et ils n'ont pas répondu. J'ai ensuite essayé l'option de chat. J'ai demandé quelles heures puis-je commerce forex. On m'a dit 247, dimanche soir jusqu'au vendredi soir. J'ai ensuite demandé à quelle heure le marché fermait vendredi soir. On m'a dit 5 P. M. J'ai demandé, alors pourquoi j'étais rempli à plusieurs ordres à 5:03 et 5:04 P. M. Après que le MARCHÉ FERME pour m'arrêter de mes positions et me renverser quelques 85 pips au-dessous de la finition s'est répandue alors on m'a dit d'attendre Jonathan. Dix minutes plus tard, un autre opérateur est entré dans la session de chat et 039Session terminée par operator039 est apparu, et je n'ai pas été autorisé à de nouvelles communications C'est la société de négociation la plus malhonnête que j'ai traité en 15 ans. Lire l'accord Il ya 8 ans SCAM Dans l'accord Il dit très clairement qu'ils peuvent couper vos informations, et peut vous fournir des informations inexactes. Si ce n'est pas une arnaque alors les escroqueries don039t existent. Ils vont voler votre argent la première chance qu'ils obtiennent. DM Il ya 7 ans SCAM WOW. Il ne m'a pas fallu longtemps pour réaliser ce que ces gars faisaient. Ils vous fermer juste hors des métiers rentables pour une raison donnée. Je pense qu'ils parient contre vous. Si vous gagnez. Ils vont vous fermer. Im imparcial parce que je sais qu'il ya de bons courtiers et de mauvais courtiers. Vous décidez par vous-même. Mais sur 3 courtiers. Ces types ont certainement une sorte de raquette d'argent en cours. Je parie que si Gain Capitol devait être enquêté. Ils seraient fermés. Il va sans dire. Ils ont perdu mon entreprise. J'utilise FXCM et Oanda. Mais mes deux amis qui ont également le commerce à temps plein Forex, j'ai personnellement pris 300K de FXCM au cours des 6 derniers mois dans le bénéfice. Ce sont des retraits nets. Ces trois services ne sont pas des escroqueries. Ils font beaucoup d'argent sur la propagation et l'intérêt et son à leur avantage pour vous faire de l'argent et faire plus de métiers. Rappelez-vous, quand vous faites de l'argent, ils espèrent que c'est d'autres services et conduit à plus de métiers. J'ai d'autres métiers 1400 sur les sites. J'ai regardé mon écart et les commissions (FXCM a une commission pour les membres d'or, mais les spreads ultra bas), il était plus de 30K l'année dernière. Pas étonnant qu'ils m'aiment. Mais mon profit était de plus de 500K. It039s pas une arnaque et pas impossible, mais c'est un travail à temps plein pour moi. Je passe 12 heures par jour 6 jours par semaine à étudier. J'ai lu tous les journaux du monde et passé des heures sur mes cartes. Alors ignorez ces imbéciles. Mais le traiter comme un travail et faire vos devoirs. Si vous le traitez comme Vegas, alors vous perdrez tout comme Vegas. C'est ma carrière. Pas différent d'être banquier, médecin ou avocat. Je suis payé très bien, mais j'ai beaucoup de stress, beaucoup de nuits blanches commerçant le marché de Londres et les jours où je perds 10-20K. Mais les jours que je fais 20-50K, ils compensent. D'après ce que je vois, le trading FX est très binaire. Ou vous pouvez le faire ou vous ne pouvez pas. Donc, la plupart perdent leur argent ou faire une tonne de celui-ci. Heureusement, je tombe dans ce dernier. J'utilise les différents sites pour la diversité et chacun a quelque chose d'unique. Mes amis aiment Forex becasue il a la plate-forme de Web et la plate-forme tenue à la main. J'aime Oanda parce qu'il a des métiers uniques tels que le commerce or contre USD à 50: 1 et aussi vous pouvez varier le levier pour chaque commerce. J'aime vraiment FXCM becasue de l'interface simple et le forum quotidien des nouvelles et du commerce qu'ils ont. FXCM a également ajouté une plate-forme web. Son agréable pour le commerce sur vos vacances quand vous avez promis à la femme de ne pas commercer et le faire de toute façon sur l'ordinateur de l'hôtel. Je n'ai pas un autre emploi, mais je pouvais le voir être utile pour le commerce au travail. Je suis certainement la preuve qu'ils ne sont pas des escroqueries avec mes retraits. Je me souviens avoir lu ce forum après avoir fait mon premier 200K en utilisant FXCM. Le lendemain, j'ai pris 100K parce que j'étais paranoïaque. Pas de problème, était dans mon compte en trois jours. Après que je devienne un membre d'or avec 10 millions dans les métiers par mois, le xfer de fil suivant était un jour. Les membres d'or obtiennent le traitement préféré. Donc, si vous voulez faire du commerce de forex, l'un des trois sont grands. Je me rends compte que pas chaque site est légitime. Mais je pense que vous pouvez faire confiance aux plus grandes tenues comme ils font plus d'argent sur la propagation et don039t besoin de vous escroquer. Peut-être que tous Wall Street est une arnaque, mais ces courtiers ne sont pas différents de Schwab ou Merrill Lynch. Vous pouvez perdre votre ss si vous don039t être prudent. J'aime aussi le roulement d'intérêt d'Oanda et de FXCM (je ne connais pas les règles de Forex) contre quelques autres courtiers. FXCM frais ou paie un simple intérêt par jour, le commerce est ouvert. Certains courtiers utilisent un système différent et il semble pénaliser les opérateurs de carry. Mais je suis habitué à la façon Oanda et FXCM, peut-être les autres sont très bien une fois que vous comprenez la façon dont ils font l'intérêt rollover. D Il ya 7 ans SCAM Don039t utiliser ce courtier I Déposez 500 et quand je voulais les retirer, le site a montré une erreur. J'ai contacté le support LIVE et l'assistant didn039t savait même quoi faire. Enfin, j'ai obtenu l'aide d'un autre assistant, qui m'a envoyé un lien vers un autre formulaire d'application - mais ici, je devrais leur fournir des informations, ma banque didn039t même chapeau je commence à penser que tout ce Forex Trading, est une grande arnaque, faite par le Gouverment de nous donner, les gens normaux un espoir falsh de faire de l'argent, mais au lieu ils nous déchirent pour encore plus alors nous avons Alex 7 ans SCAM Forex société a volé mon argent. J'étais un client de la société Forex. Un jour, j'ai obtenu un bénéfice sur le commerce de devises. J'ai pris mon profit et j'étais heureux avec cela. Mais après 2 minutes tout mon profit a disparu et une très grande perte est apparue. D'abord je n'ai pas compris comment cela peut arriver. J'ai pensé que c'était une erreur de logiciel et j'ai redémarré ma plateforme de trading. Rien ne change. Ensuite, j'ai vérifié mon historique de négociation pour voir ce qui s'est passé. Et j'ai trouvé trois fausses affaires. Je n'ai pas fait ces affaires inutiles. J'ai essayé de demander au représentant du Forex pourquoi ils ont mis trois fausses affaires sur mon compte. Mais il ne voulait pas me parler. Donc, la société Forex a volé tant d'argent de mon compte. Emmett digimode Il ya 7 ans, j'ai testé cette société avec près d'une centaine de comptes de démonstration sur la plate-forme MT4, en utilisant des noms différents. J'ai aussi testé forex avec 5 comptes en direct pour moi et mes amis afin qu'ils m'ont dans les noms différent aussi. Permettez-moi de vous dire aussi que j'ai testé environ 30 autres entreprises avec des comptes démo et environ 3 autres entreprises avec des comptes en direct. J'ai découvert que Forex se distingue pour être le meilleur dans la démo et le compte réel. Je n'ai jamais connu de tricherie dans les comptes en direct, j'ai eu des pointes qui déclenche mes limites de profit plutôt que d'arrêter la perte. Un autre point que je veux faire au sujet de cette compagnie basée sur mon expérience avec le marché de forex. Le seul compte de démonstration qui emmule compte en direct près de 100 est celui que vous ouvrez avec Forex. Vous obtenez autant de requotes dans le compte démo que dans le compte live, il n'y a absolument aucune différence entre la démo et les comptes en direct, donc après avoir perdu de l'argent, je pratique maintenant exclusivement avec des comptes démo forex. C'est la seule compagnie que je puisse recommander à tout le monde. Contactez-moi à forexbody (at) gmail si vous souhaitez une confirmation supplémentaire. Andris Il ya 7 ans Cela m'étonne, combien les gens peuvent gémir sur certains courtier (pas seulement forex), que cela s'est passé et que c'est arrivé. Allez - admettez simplement que vous n'êtes pas un commerçant succès et thats that. Beaucoup d'entre vous dnt se rendre compte qu'il n'est jamais la même si vous le commerce sur la démo et de l'argent réel. C'est là que le 95 arrive - c'est dans votre tête. J'ai été le commerce avec eux depuis 5 ans maintenant, et non, je ne suis pas un gros coup de temps faisant des millions par mois, im ce gars avec quelques milliers de dollars pour jouer avec. Oui, il ya eu quelques problèmes avec le forex, à la fois techniques et peuples faute, et aussi ma faute aussi. Donc, voici les downers d'abord, certains sont juste mes voeux, mais néanmoins. 1. Première dans la première politique de sortir - je n'aime pas cela, mais encore une fois, il est maintenant possible de fermer des lots individuels manuellement, mais vous ne pouvez pas mettre des ordres sur ceux. 2. Les gens de soutien sont parfois inconscients de ce qui se passe, et oui, pour cela seul, il devrait mériter 1-2 étoiles au mieux. Ensuite, cela dépend, et vous pourriez obtenir une personne utile à l'autre bout de chatphone. 3. Spikes et lag pendant les nouvelles, oui, parfois 30-40 pips, mais cela va pour tous les courtiers là-bas, et forex isnt le pire dont j'ai essayé. 4. Différence entre les graphiques et les prix donnés, parfois 10 pips ou plus. Pas très utile pour le scalping tranchant. 5. Aucune couverture des positions. (Tho je pourrais être mal à ce sujet) Probablement il ya plus, mais je ne peux pas me rappeler sur place. Maintenant, le bon: 1. L'argent déposant de retirer - jamais eu un problème avec cela: wworks comme un charme pour moi. Oui, cela prend du temps, mais c'est vrai pour tout. Gardez à l'esprit, qu'un transfert de fil standart prend 10 jours bancaires à passer (2 semaines), les chèques peuvent prendre 2 mois, donc si vous êtes petit joueur de temps, utilisez revenir à la carte de crédit, si possible. 2. Contrairement à certains autres là-bas, ils n'ont pas cette chose horrible que vous pouvez mettre des ordres seulement 5-10 pips loin de votre position, peut prendre même 1 pip si vous le souhaitez. 3. Leur commentaire interne, l'analyse, les stratégies sont assez bonnes. 4. L'accès par téléphone mobile - j'utilise beaucoup pour voir ce qui se passe, alors que pas à l'ordinateur. Donc, pour souligner tout cela - si vous êtes nouveau (je veux dire que vous avez échangé quelques mois sur la démo), ne vont pas pour cela, essayez de trouver un endroit où vous pouvez échanger supermicro FX, et ne mettez pas tout votre argent là-dedans. Pour commencer avec 250 est tout simplement rediculous, vous êtes presque assuré de le perdre. Apprenez vos cordes avant de commencer, parce que, comme je l'ai dit, sa psychologie totalement différente lorsque vous le commerce avec de l'argent réel. Alors continuez, trouvez un endroit où vous pouvez mettre 20-30 et jouer avec 1cent un pip, et faire cela pendant au moins 6 mois avant d'aller plus loin. Si son ne fonctionne pas - probablement le marché des changes n'est pas la chose pour vous. Allez négocier des actions ou jouer à la loterie ou au casino. Éduquez-vous, lire des livres, peut-être même aller à un séminaire ou quelque chose. Forex est l'une des 3 plates-formes que j'utilise, et si je n'étais pas si paranoïaque de dire quotdont mis tous vos oeufs dans un panier que j'utiliserais celui-là seul. Last but not least - je ne travaille pas pour eux, je ne suis affilié en aucune façon, ou payé pour écrire des critiques. Juste un client heureux (la plupart des fois :)). E. W. Il ya 7 ans I039ve été le commerce avec succès des actions pendant sept ans et a décidé d'essayer le commerce de devises. J'ai ouvert mon compte en août après un examen superficiel d'autres sites. J'avoue que j'étais très nerveux après avoir lu tous les commentaires ici. Mais, je dois dire que ce site est très bon j'aime vraiment la plateforme de négociation. Facile à utiliser, propre et une bonne configuration. C'est MALGRÉ-moi avoir effectué plutôt mal dans mon premier mois de devises de négociation. Je comprends qu'il ya une courbe d'apprentissage et je sais que I039m va aller mieux (ma performance de la dernière semaine d'août a vraiment tourné autour). Le processus de dépôt et de retrait est très bien et le soutien en direct en ligne est très bien aussi. Rajesh Il ya 7 ans SCAM Sauf pour un type qui dit qu'il a fait 500k (semble être une histoire de pêche) tout le monde a perdu de l'argent. Cependant, parmi les personnes qui ont perdu de l'argent il semble y avoir deux catégories. Il ya ceux qui ont perdu et blâmer le courtier et il ya d'autres qui ont perdu et se blâmer. J'ai mis 2500 en forex et échangé pendant plus de six mois et a perdu tout cela. Ils m'ont promis des écarts plus serrés et m'ont facturé des spreads plus larges, m'ont fermé au mauvais moment et ont tiré quelques trucs de perte d'arrêt aussi. J'ai pensé que j'étais dupe mais en lisant certains de ces messages, je commence à penser que c'est une vraie boutique de seau. Indépendamment du fait que nous sommes des commerçants mauvais et pleurnicher après avoir perdu, je pense qu'il ya plus que suffisamment de comportement contraire à l'éthique ici pour exiger une enquête. Quelqu'un at-il essayé de rapporter ces gars à la NFA. Pas de chance avec cette approche. J'ai utilisé un compte pratique avec Forex ou Gain Capital pendant environ 2 mois maintenant et je n'ai jamais eu un problème comme indiqué ci-dessus. Beaucoup de temps, je pense que le client fait quelque chose ou doesn039t comprendre quelque chose puis juste le blâmer sur la société. Cela est particulièrement vrai lorsque le client perde de l'argent. Je dis essayer la société pour le dépôt minimum de 250. Si vous n'avez pas au moins beaucoup à perdre, alors vous êtes sur le mauvais marché. Daniel Il ya 7 ans, j'utilise GAIN (Forex) avec NinjaTrader. Je n'ai pas encore de problèmes avec l'entreprise. L'ouverture était facile, les dépôts étaient rapides et les données fiables. Je trouve ça drôle que tous ces posts parlent de métiers liquidés pour quotno reason. quot Apparemment, ces gens ont des soldes de compte très faible et shouldn039t être du commerce à tous. Je n'ai jamais eu de liquidation d'un poste, mais c'est peut-être parce que j'ai un équilibre assez important pour couvrir la taille de mon métier. Cette société n'est certainement pas une arnaque et il est triste que tant de gens les marquent comme une arnaque parce qu'ils n'ont aucune idée de comment le commerce avec des niveaux élevés de marge. Si vous avez étiqueté cette entreprise comme une escroquerie que vous soit a) ont si peu d'argent que tout le commerce que vous faites est vulnérable à la volatilité et ils voient que comme un risque et de liquidation b) n'ont aucune idée comment le commerce avec la marge ou c) Pour exploiter tout votre compte sur un seul métier. Tous ceux qui méritent d'avoir votre position liquidée. Je recommande fortement soit ils NinjaTrader ou MetaTrader plates-formes, comme tout commerçant réel le recommanderait. J'étais très excité de voir NinjaTrader fait équipe avec GAIN et vous obtenez une copie gratuite de NinjaTrader. Pour tous ces diots qui pensent que c'est une arnaque: pourquoi NinjaTrader (l'une des plates-formes de négociation les plus populaires pour les vrais commerçants) équipe avec une entreprise qui est une arnaque Ils wouldn039t. Vous êtes retardé et ne devrait pas être la monnaie de négociation. Permettez-moi de deviner, vous avez ouvert un compte à terme trop et perdu de l'argent parce que vous avez exploité votre compte entier sur un contrat Apprenez à commercer. Grande compagnie, période. Pamela il ya 7 ans SCAM Arnaque totale. Soyez très prudent. J'ai aimé leur compte démo et a eu un bon succès avec elle. Quand je suis allé vivre avec forex, tout a changé. Je soupçonne qu'ils sont engagés dans des activités illicites. J'ai été impliqué dans une école de forex en ligne qui les recommandait fortement. Quand le commerce en direct avec eux s'est avéré être si impossible, par rapport à la démo, j'ai commencé à sentir que j'avais été mis en place. Ce n'est que spéculation et peut être loin de la base, mais ils travaillent vraiment dur pour s'assurer que vous ne profitent pas. I don039t croient les commentaires sur faire l'argent énorme avec le forex. Je soupçonne que le courtier a écrit ces. Je peux être assez nouveau au forex, mais je fais assez bien à elle, tant que je suis très attentif. Je ne suis pas simplement un idiot forex qui blâme le courtier pour mes échecs. Quelque chose de très étrange s'est passé lors de la négociation avec cette société. Je ne les utiliserai JAMAIS et ne les recommanderais jamais à personne. Anthony Il ya 6 ans, je suis un client très frustré de leurs comptes MT4 UK. Aujourd'hui, le 11 mars 2010, leur système est en panne toute la journée. En plus de cela, ils ont été très unaccomadating et ne sont pas disposés à faire des compensations ou même renoncer à des frais d'échange. Je ne recommande pas ce courtier à qui que ce soit. VS il ya 6 ans Eh bien, vous devez savoir que forex a une aggrement spéciale avec la banque d'amérique, qui stipule que fors fournira BoA avec la liste des chèques qu'ils autorisent à cah out. Donc, si vous avez fermé ur acct et Tradesatation vous envoyer un chèque, qui est de Forex, que le contrôle maust être sur la liste. Lorsque vous allez à BoA ils ne peuvent jamais se procurer de forex. Donc, u finissent par courir autour et faire des appels aux gens tradestation, qui n'ont également aucune idée à ce sujet. J'ai un chèque de forex, mais Boa ne peut même pas l'accepter pour le dépôt. Il ya déjà plus d'un mois. Peut-être il est plus logique de leur payer 25 et faire le fil. Timur Il y a 6 ans, je suis avec eux depuis deux ans maintenant. Je peux dire qu'ils ne sont pas une arnaque. Oui j'ai drainé mon compte tant de fois étant avec eux mais maintenant je fais l'argent. Aucune douleur aucun gain :) Je ne les blâme pas, parce que c'était dû à mon incompétence. Je ne scalpe pas avec eux. Ma stratégie est à moyen terme, donc je ne donne pas une merde sur les dérapages et les nouvelles. Ils sont compétents et ont une bonne équipe de soutien. Il n'y a eu aucun problème à retirer de l'argent de mon compte non plus. Conclusion: Ceux qui se plaignent ne peuvent pas échanger. Cheers et bonne chance keith Il ya 6 ans SCAM Cette société est une arnaque. Je sais exactement ce que je fais sur le marché. Je l'ai étudié pendant 3 ans et je l'ai pratiqué pendant plusieurs mois sur un compte de démonstration de la leur. J'ai finalement ouvert un nouveau compte avec eux et devinez quoi 1. Leur serveur en direct est mort lente rendant impossible pour vous de faire vos mouvements sur les bons points d'entrée et de sortie. 2. Ils continuent de dire qu'ils ajoutent de nouveaux serveurs. Mais c'est un taureau. Vous appelez leur numéro 800 et le même type que je discutais sur le chat en direct reprend. C'est ainsi que ces gens sont petits. 3. Je demande au type Damon de me donner le département qui est en charge de l'assistance technique et il dit qu'il n'en a pas parce qu'ils sont des numéros internes. Ils rendent les serveurs live lent afin qu'ils puissent vous forcer à perdre vos métiers. I comme un commerçant expert de trouver qu'il est difficile de négocier avec eux. TOUS LES NOUVEAUX. S'il vous plaît trouver un autre courtier et heureux PIPPING il ya 6 ans woah woah woah keith, vous avez étudié forex pendant trois ans et sont un maître auto-proclamé venir maintenant, qui semble ridicule. Beaucoup de commerçants passent par beaucoup beaucoup de beaucoup d'années de commerce et ne s'appellent pas des experts. Mon expérience personnelle avec le forex n'est pas tout ce grand. Jusqu'ici, j'ai placé un peu plus de 1000 métiers avec eux. I039ve seulement été trading 4x pour 2 ans et ont live (compte) avec eux pour seulement plus de 8 mois. I039ve essayé fxcm039s micro crap, et bien que I039ve entendu certaines personnes parlent là haut comptes standard, leur plate-forme micro ressemble juste à un turd smearing mon écran. I039m en utilisant la plate-forme forex MT4, I039m pas un grand fan de la propagation, gbpjpy obtient un petit bonkers ici et là, donc je ne scalp il. J'ai été perdre de l'argent à ma propre stupidité pour les 6 derniers mois, et it039s été un helluva grande expérience d'apprentissage. It039s pas comme j'ai mis ma vie épargne ici, et si vous avez fait, vous ne devriez pas être le commerce, le commerce avec l'argent vous don039t besoin de payer votre loyer avec. Forex n'a pas fermé aucun de mes métiers. Sur 1000 métiers j'ai obtenu 2 faux contrats. (Essayer de jouer gbpjpy mais got gpdchf ou quelque chose comme ça) encore une fois, ma faute, je dois avoir 2x vérifié le commerce. Im seulement 23, et le plan sur continuer mon expérience d'apprentissage pour un temps loooong. if you can039t take the pain, don039t play the game STARCRAFT 2 IS COMING OUT SOON SO QUIT FCKING CRYING AND GET READY TO RUUUUMMMMBBBLLLLLLEEEEE John Smith 6 years ago Hi, i am working with Forex for 2 years now. A few months ago i have decided to open a MT4 account with them. But i actually become a customer of and afiliate of them which is Gain Capital Forex. uk. After i started to trade and open another account for working through Zulutrade station they have send me a notice in wich they are anouncing me my boths accounts are terminated. The problem is that i am in DD position right now and they will profit from my loss as they are asking me to close all my open positions on monday morning or they will close them for me. Bellow i will show you the notice they have send it to me. I have to tell you that they didn039t phone me before that and ask me something that they found it unclear. They don039t care about customer and please stay out and run away as you can from this brokers because is so simple to let you open an account and then they will terminate that account without you being able to decide anything. Please look bellow what they are sending to me : Dear John Smith, Please accept this letter as formal notice regarding FOREX UK039s recent decision to close the above referenced FOREX UK account you hold with us and effectively terminate the customer agreement between your person and FOREX UK in full accordance with the agreement with such termination becoming effective as of the date of this letter. As a result of a recent review of your account activity, we determined we are no longer in a position to continue extending our services to you. As such, we have determined to close the account. Please note your account appears to have open positions and has a current remaining balance of 1730.36. You will have until 17:00 PM on July 12th to close your position. After which time we will automatically liquidate all open positions and terminate your account. To receive your funds, please complete, sign and submit the attached withdrawal request which is provided herein for your convenience Should you have any questions following this communication, please feel free in communicating directly to ComplianceForex. I thank you for your time. Thank you Kind Regards, David Fan Risk and Operations Manager GAIN Capital Vanessa 6 years ago SCAM These guys are pure scam. I had like 5000 in my account and I was trading 1 standard lot with a mental stop loss (because these guys WILL chase your stop loss if you put it there). My trade was going in the right direction, then the platform disconnected. It took me an hour later to get back in and guess what, they sold my position for 600 loss. That039s no freaking where near the margin, mind you. I bailed out ASAP. David Lonie 6 years ago SCAM Ho Boy. man. what the hell kind of site is this anyway. I was making a profit on a position and it still closed liquidated. below is an actual Live Chat with one of there Agent Brad right after this happened. Friday 4am to 5am October 15, 2010. enjoy for your reading pleasure. Beginning of Transmission Please wait for a site operator to respond. You are now chatting with 039Brad039 Brad: Hello david lonie, welcome to Client Services. May I have your email address to better assist you david lonie: email omitted Brad: Thank you for your information, how may I assist you david lonie: ok. this has happened to me repeatedly. my position which was up over 700 just vanished david lonie: granted a practice account039 david lonie: but i did not close the position. I was making money fake david lonie: so what gives Brad: I will look into this for you. Brad: One moment please. david lonie: i even had a Stop Loss and Limit set Brad: I do see this. david lonie: k. y did this happen Brad: After you increased your position, and then the market went against you slightly after the last trade, you feel below the margin requirement for this position and were liquidated. david lonie: that039s nonsensical. the margin should have been fine. a measly 96 would not have affected this. i was down over 2000 earlier which was way below margin and nothing happened only after i quotmanuallyquot ended the bleeding. your answer does not make sense. hence nonsensical david lonie: what else you got david lonie: this does not extend confidence in doing business with your firm david lonie: unless you can achieve some correctness to the platform. I am afraid I will have to close my Live account Brad: This is what happened in this case. Brad: One moment please. david lonie: and the case where i was going under in excess of 2000 well below margin with no liquidation But a closure with a positive revenue is justified as liquidation Make sense of this or I close my account. Brad: One moment please. Brad: The rate reached a high of 1.4114. At that time, the margin requirement for 900,000 lots would have been 25,440.86 david lonie: right and i was beating with the stream not against it. Brad: I do understand that. However, when you increased your position it put you close to liquidation. Once the market went against you a little you fell below the margin requirement. david lonie: my initial purchase price was around 1.4080 for 700,000 lots then I purchased another at around 1.40921 for 200,000 your 900,000, an avg. of 1.40857 approx.. still your margin argument is not making sense. david lonie: I was still ahead green david lonie: i was positive Not negative david lonie: if anything the last position should have been closed Not the whole position. that doesnt make sense. Brad: Whether you are in the positive or negative is not the issue here. david lonie: sure it is Brad: When you made the last trade it put you at risk. david lonie: if i am positive 16,000 lets say, my position is not going to close due to a lack of margin Brad: It can still close if you keep increasing your position. david lonie: the only risk was to the Forex practice pocket book. I will be closing my Live account. this is not the only site. eToro seems to be doing a much better job on their practice accounts. which usually translates to accurate and correct RealTime awareness Brad: I do apologize for this. However, it is your responsibility to maintain the margin requirement for your open positions. When you increased the position, you put yourself at risk for liquidation if the market went against you at that trade. david lonie: quotIfquot meant as under your meta-physical hunch Now, you are a prophet and fortune teller. sensationnel. Brad: Is there anything else I can assist you with david lonie: probably not Brad: Thank you for visiting. Should you have further questions or comments please log on to chat, email, call us at 1-877-FOREXGO (367-3946) or internationally at 1-908-731-0750. end of transmission So there you have it. I closed my account that day. Have not looked back. I was ahead kicking thier butt then they liquidated my account because quotifquot the market took a turn I would not be capable of a Stop Loss. I did graduate with a double major, one being Economics the other Financial Capital Mrkts. I am pretty sure I could handle a turn in the market. Here039s what happened to make me change my mind and start looking for a new broker: I 039Martingaled039 a position after very careful analysis. Btw 039Martingaling039 isn039t something I often do or recommend for beginners (or the faint of heart) and definitely don039t do it unless you have a large account AND you know EXACTLY what you039re doing as it can seriously bite you in the a. I was in a trade which had been losing money but had reversed and was shaping up to be VERY profitable. As insurance, I reduced my position (just in case I wasn039t correct) and the next thing I know my ENTIRE position was liquidated due to a separate order being placed by their system. AN ORDER WHICH I NEVER EXECUTED No stops were triggered WTF. What was about to be my all time most profitable trade ended up being a very sizeable loss for me. When I called them they said I must have done it What Why would I do that Basically they accepted zero responsibility and insinuated that I obviously don039t know what I am doing and I must have done it Unbelievable Btw as a side note, it turns out that my strategy proved to be 100 correct and I would have made an outstanding profit - thanks for nothing Forex Other issues I have had with them include - - Charts are sometimes slow when compared with other trading platforms. So what you think is happening ISN039T actually what IS happening - I observed this phenomenon most on their 5min chart (I have video evidence to prove this) - Issues with withdrawal requests e. g. they would just cancel a withdrawal request even though I had a large account and almost 100 margin available. Also delays in receiving my money e. g. they say 1-2 days but sometimes I have had to wait 4-7 days to receive my money. - Telling me my bank account details are incorrect when I triple checked them AND they are correct AND it039s the same bank account details they used to previously do my withdrawals. - On their website they say that as a non-US customer you can deposit funds into their bank account. This is when the fun begins On their site they list their bank account details. So I go online into my bank account and setup an online direct transfer to Forex and to make it easy I include my Forex trading account number as a reference for them. Then (and this happened EVERY time) they would email me after a day or two and say they don039t know where the funds came from. What I would then have to print off a statement and either fax or email it to them to 1) Prove it was my money to begin with. 2) Show it is my bank account Seriously let039s get into the 21st century already - I also had to get on their case and keep asking them to release their bonusincentive funds to my account even though I had more than met their trading requirements. To be fair there are a few plus points: I would get my money deposited into my account eventually, monthly interest paid on account balance was nice, decent enough 039Live Chat039, no withdrawal fees (due to my account size) and quite decent promotions from time to time. Anyway I think that039s enough and I039ve made my point. My tip, find a broker you feel you can trust - this is crucial to Forex trading success Forex trading is challenging enough without feeling like your broker could let you down at any moment. Good luck trading Max - Sydney 4 years ago SCAM Hi Guys, Thanks for this information, I039ve been playing with this market makers in Sydney for nearly 2 years and I lost 160k. I couldn039t believe this stories until I saw that they close my wining positions without my permission with excuse of reaching to the margin call, this bad, don039t waste your time and money with them. Aamir Saeed 3 years ago I lost 500 GBP with these criminals. They would close a position without any reason, Initially I deposited 250 GBP and added 250 again, they find one reason of the other and positions can be closed as fast as they open wiping out money from your account. On top of that, I didn039t even trade in forex, I was doing commodities. I have asked for return of my remaining 47 or so GBP and am still waiting. DO NOT waste your money with these guys. Dontbegypped 3 years ago With the understanding that they are counter party to your trade, one would keep an open mind for dealer plugins and such. I speak from a on amp off relationship with ForexUKUSUKUS, a Gain Capital division for the poor in monetary and big on dreams. News trading is far the worst, that if you held a position prior to it or just got unlucky, you can see all the delays in the price action keeping you humble. Yes, you could take advantage of this and they will honor it, but the negatives far outweigh the positive. The last despicable act came horror before my eyes. The EURUSD position I held changed to some other currency. No hot keys were pressed or accidentally scrolled. In fact, the journal was completely erased of any records even though no MT4 restarts either on or on VPS. Overall, a dealerbroker can delay, slip, disconnect, requote, or give show trade context busy etc, but changing one039s position was the final straw. At least, withdrawals and service is met with expectancy. Sanctimony 3 years ago SCAM I wouldn039t suggest the platform in general. The FTP platform is extremely sluggish and it is impossible to define defaults for market positions. The worst thing though is that they will arbitrarily close or change your position without your approval. This hovers on being borderline illegal. They will ignore a losing position and let you rack up losses, but quickly close a winning one. Their TOS probably has a hidden clause which allows them to tamper with your positions and close them at their own will, but I fail to see why anyone would continue to trade with this company once it happens to them. Would you continue trading stocks at a broker that suddenly sells off your entire holdings in a company because the stock surges upwards in price I think the analogy is fair and valid. This company is a fraud, plain and simple. I do conflict arbitrage on behalf of a Forex forum and at least 80 of the cases pertain to this site. I personally never traded here, but saw all the screenshots, video captures etc. myself, and talked to scammed customers on the phone. You should make physical records of your trading history with this company. Use a video feed if you have to. If they erase or close your positions without asking you in advance, take them to court. sam 3 years ago SCAM Its a scam. They are manipulating their software It seems that while you are trading, someone at the other end can speed up or slow down the software. They store your emotional pattern and play with it. Nasty business..I lost 5000. I dont regret it, charge to experience and donations to US govt. why they allow or not notice such scams. Huge Losses Forex 2 years ago SCAM First and foremost Forex makes up prices in there virtual environment, and they charge tremendous amounts of points. This is not real trades this is fake. DO NOT LISTEN TO POSITIVE REVIEWS AS I WAS TRICKED TOO. I lost over 3k I was upset then I started viewing MT4 on another site and was completely amazed by there 3 to 5 second price difference. Megan 9 months ago SCAM COMPLETE SCAM I made an account, deposited 2500 and started trading. I made a couple hundred dollars and requested to have it sent to my bank account for withdrawal. The time frame stated it could take up to 48 hours. It039s been over 7 week days. If I can039t even get that money out I039m probably not going to be able to get my 2500 back either. I thought I did my research before working with them but I guess not. I didn039t lose money on trades. I lost money because they wouldn039t give me earnings. Will be attempting to refund my initial deposit soon. George Harris 8 months ago SCAM I am having a continual problem withdrawing fund from my account. Gain Capital039s website states that it can take up to 2 business days to quotprocessquot your withdrawal. In reality, it takes them 5-7 days to return my funds. When I contact them to comlain, they blame my credit card company for the delays. Problem with that is I have a friend at my bank who is able to view the banks ledger and determine when funds hit my credit card. Turns put thae problem is Gain Capital. They dont like withdrawals so they delay processing them for up to a week befor releasing funds back to a credit card. Gain sends an email quotconfirmingquot my withdrawal request the same day I make the request. The funds are removed from my account within an hour by Gain, but they dont release them back to my card for 7-10 days. I wonder how much interest Gain is making off my quotfunds in limboquot that have bern removed from my account but not returned to me in a timely manner. Ambiguous 8 months ago I have read the comments about Forex and find the argument that Gain Capitals clients do not understand the risk rather funny and deceptive. I understand that risks are very prevalent in CFD039s, spot, or whatever you would like to call the contracts. There is one very big problem that I personally faced with Forex. The company suspended trading 3 consecutive times when they owed my own account. I approached the service department with these issues and was told that technical difficulties were the reason for the suspensions. Without honoring the orders placed while under suspension I was told that reduced spread would be offered for a short period of time. Now, to tell clients or potential clients that they do not understand risk is absurd. Clients of Gain must compete with slippage, rouge ticks, ect. Yet if clients do quotbeatquot the traditional and understood risks they can be stuck with a quotproductquot that is not exchangeable with a contracted service company who039s business is solely to make these exchanges. So, Gain Capital has one or more problems that can be identified as a scamunethical practice and please understand they will operate in this manner (I was a client for years). They have technology that is seemingly faulty when it does not benefit the company, they manually shut down (suspend) trades, or have routine liquidity problems to cover their own debts, ect. With Gain providing white label solutions for a variety of companies it would behoove of investorstraders to understand these issues are not isolated to forex and have been addressed, without resolve, to Gain Capital and their legal team. At best this is an unethical and immoral company. At worst they are the scam that so many have already labeled themForex Com Reviews and Ratings anomymous 9 years ago SCAM Hello folks. Welcome to the world of FRAUDEX, which is at least how you039ll feel once you039ve been with Gain Capital. same as Tradestation Forex Broker - BEWARE. you have a position on, news happens, you get out and they claim you exited too fast. cause they039ll go after a stop that isn039t even there anymore - aka stop huntingfishing - and will screw you BIG TIME every time you get out with a profit, they039ll get you in again with similar excuses. ABSOLUTELY INCOMPETENT. I039m so dissapointed and Disgusted I feel like giving up on Trading Forex. my question now is. since abuse of customers is so wide spread amongst these forex brokers, WHEN THE HELL WILL THE GOVERNMENT STEP IN AND REGULATE THESE CRIMINALS. CAUSE THAT039S WHAT THEY ARE. THEY039LL TRADE AGAINST THEIR CUSTOMERS AND NOONE IS DOING A THING ABOUT IT. SO THE ABUSES WILL CONTINUE AS LONG AS THE GOVERNMENT(S) DON039T DO A THING ABOUT IT. STAY AWAY, CAVEAT EMPTOR. YOU WILL LOSE MOST IF NOT ALL YOUR MONEY LIKE MANY HAVE - IF YOU DON039T BELIEVE ME CHECK OUT OTHER FOREX RATING WEBSITES AS WELL - PEACE rob 9 years ago SCAM Avoid Forex. Never open an account with them, never send any money. if you have done it close the account and move somewhere else. I039ve had a hellish beginning with them. I had bad feelings but Ithought. what039s the heck. people entrust them with millions of . they would not scam me of measly 1000 which I intended to open my account with. When I filled the application and sent to them I was asked to provide them with two pieces of Id, one of Id verification and one for place of living. I am Canadian. I sent them Canadian Citizenship card and driver Id with address. I was also pushed into sending money before even the account is open (to speed up the process). So I did. Then I am getting response that the driver039s liocense is O. K. but my Canadian Citizenship card is NOT GOOD as an ID document BECAUSE IT DOES NOT HAVE. EXPIRATION DATE. (Like citizenship is something expiration date should be put on)). So I sent my government issued health card, containing my address and expiration date. NO good. It has been already almost a month since I started the application process. They requested some utility bills or other correspondence. citing some HOME INSECURITY LAWS or some other NAZI GESTAPO RULES. I felt interrogated like some criminal or Terror Suspect. I went to another company, which is reputable. they opened the acxcount with only driver039s license. no questions asked within 1 day. I decided to not bother anymore with Forex. I called the company and requested my money back. the lady from customer service started first to do pitch sale to discourage me from withdrawing the money. I said no. I told I want my money back She promissed to wire them immediately. she told me also she does not need any wiring instructions since she knows where the money came from. After few days I called her to enquire about the status of the wire transfer. She told that she did not wired the money because I should sent them quotWire request form with signaturequot. This is what I039ve done it. waited another 10 days. money did not come to my account. I called the lady again. She tell me that they cannot comply with the request because I don039t have account with them. pitching me again to open the account. I refused. so she told me that then I have to go to my bank and make quotRECALLquot of the money. it is what I have done last week. over 5 days ago. Today I checked in my bank. THE MONEY IS STILL NOT THERE. The bank is going to trace what has happened to the money. J'attends. More and more impatient. DON039t DEAL WITH FOREX. they are crooks and scammers. They will scam you from the beginning and you will fill like a crp after you get scked into their game. R forex questrade 8 years ago SCAM Forex questrade Canada scam On Thursday night sept 4th I was short gbpjpy and entered a one cancels the other stop loss and limit order. The market was moving very quickly and ended staying up all night making good money. I stayed short but when Friday morning came and the trend reversed before I could get out I thought I would remove the stop loss because I believed that the market would go short again in the following weeks. I went to the positions manager window and tried to cancel but the cancel button would not work so I hit the modify button and modified the position to read zero stop loss and zero limit. I then went to my reports page so I could copy the info and to verify that it had gone through but I could not get any reports to work on my system. I thought it was my computers fault so I rebooted my computer and re - started the trading platform. I was still not able to access the reports. I went to see if I had to update java since it is a java platform but it was updated already. By this time it was almost 3 Mountain Time and questrade would be closed and they are very hard to get a hold of anyway and I had to get ready for work. I checked again to see if I had cancelled the stop loss and on my platform it said that I had and all the numbers were at zero so I thought I had nothing to worry about. Also my wife was there with me the whole day and witnessed all that I had done. on Sunday when I opened my platform I had no open positions and again thought it was my computer glitching so I rebooted it a few times to see if my positions would show up. to no avail so I phoned forex the parent company who owns questrade and told them of the situation. the man there said he could see no reason why my positions were closed as he did not see a stop loss entered and there was no reason for a margin call, but he said I would have to wait till Monday to talk to questrade as they were the ones who closed my positions. on Monday I spoke with Paul the manager who always is rude and arrogant with me and said if I had a bigger account and traded more then everyone would be happy and this would never happen. he then said I would never find proof of what I was saying and that they were going to stick with the results of the stop loss and not compensate me in anyway as I could never prove anything that I was saying. I accused them of manipulating my trading platform and of erasing all the electronic footprints and of shutting me out of my reports so I could not verify that I cancelled the stop loss. he said he didn039t care because I could never prove it. please help me in dealing with this company and this problem. has anybody had problems with these guys. sometimes just before big news announcements or before or during big market moves I will not be able to get on my trading platform. they have very limited calling hours and are very hard to reach but when I do get through they will say that no system is perfect and that there are times when there are glitches and that039s just a part of the risk of trading and nothing they can do or will do about it. I got the same answer from fxcm when they do the same thing but eventually they reimbursed me for some losses and admitted it was their fault the platform was not working, but it never truly compensates for all the stress and missed trades and huge losses experienced because of this. are there any brokers who do not do this. who do not make it impossible to get on the platform to trade or to even get them on the phone. please let me know. also be aware of this. if you have a margin call they will let the trade go way beyond the required margin and even if it039s more than you have in the account they will demand you pay the dept. in their hand book it clearly states that a trader can never lose more than they invest. in real situations though it can happen and they will say that the market moves fast and that039s the best price they could get. I fought this though and after many fights over the phone finally won a bit and did not have to pay the amount over and above my account balance but I never got back the amount required for margin. so please beware you can lose more than whets in your account and certainly every penny of your account. please be aware that some companies have complete access to your trading platform 24 hours a day whether you are on it or not. questrade has and knows everyone039s password to their platforms. some companies do not allow this because they can not regulate and be responsible for every broker or worker. but questrade has found a way to erase all electronic footprints of any thing at least that039s what is implied by what they say and do. so be very careful of the company you deal with. they have all the power to manipulate anything and to get away with it legally. questrade has all the password knowledge so be careful sal 8 years ago platform buggy, but overall they are not bad, always filled orders as expected, very good customer service. i dont know what all these folks are talking about, i found them to be just fine. my main complaint is that thier windows based trading platform is mediocre at best. Kyle 8 years ago Keep in mind that 95 of retail Forex traders lose because they don039t have the slimmest clue of what theyr039e doing. They try to play tennis against pro tennis players and just can039t understand why they lose their money. Look, Gain isn039t the one taking your money, it039s me. I039m one of the 5 who spent years studying and you039re one of the 95 who over-leveraged themselves, spun the wheel and said quotblackquot. Guess what gamblers, you lost. Every transaction requires a counter-party and 99 of the time that counter-party is not the broker but other traders. I hate these review sites because they039re dominated by losing traders crying quotIt039s a scamquot, quotThey stopped me outquot. Yes, this whole trillion dollar industry is a conspiracy to knock you out of your cheesy 10,000 position. Try using less leverage, move your stop loss to a reasonable, meaningful position and THEY CAN039T STOP YOU OUT. If you get stopped out by the broker it means you took a very bad position. Gamblers lose, so did you, stop whining.. Alex 8 years ago SCAM Forex company stole my money I was a customer of Forex company. One day i got a profit on currency trading. I took my profit and i was happy with that. But after 2 minutes all my profit disappeared and a very large loss appeared. First i did not understand how this can happened. I thought this is a software error and i restarted my trading platform. Nothing changes. Then i checked my trading history to see what happened. And i found three false bargains. I did not make those unprofitable bargains. I tried to ask Forex representative why they put three false bargains on my account. But he did not want to talk to me. So Forex company stole so much money from my account. Steve in the U. S. 8 years ago I have been trading futures for a long time and decided to try Forex. I made 3800 the first week and 700 this past week, even though it was a holiday week. When the market closed at 5 P. M. Friday night, I stepped away to take out the trash. When I got back I was shocked to find out that I was filled on my stop-loss and stop loss plus reversal orders over 85 pips below the closing bid-ask spread on two currencies. This put me at a loss of 1400 from were I was four minutes ago I contacted three different departments via e-mail about this, and they did not respond. I then tried the chat option. I asked what hours may I trade forex. I was told 247, Sunday evening through Friday evening. I then asked what time does the market close on Friday night. I was told 5 P. M. I asked, then why was I filled on multiple orders at 5:03 and 5:04 P. M. after the MARKET CLOSED to stop me out of my positions and reverse me some 85 pips below the ending spread I was then told to wait for Jonathan. Ten minutes later another operator entered the chat session and 039Session ended by operator039 appeared, and I was not allowed further communications This is the most dishonest trading firm that I have dealt with in 15 years. Reading the agreement 8 years ago SCAM In the agreement It says very clearly that they can cut off your information, and can provide you with inaccurate information. If that is not a scam then scams don039t exist. They will steal your money the first chance that they get. DM 7 years ago SCAM WOW. Didnt take me long to realize what these guys were doing. They just close you out of profitable trades for any given reason. I think they are betting against you. if you win. they will shut you down. Im unbiased because i know there are good brokers and bad brokers. You decide for yourself. but out of 3 brokers. These guys definetly have some sort of money racket going on. Im betting that if Gain Capitol were to get investigated. they would be shut down. Needless to say. they have lost my business. I use FXCM and Oanda. But my two friends who also trade full time use Forex I have personally taken 300K out of FXCM over the last 6 months in profit. Thats net withdrawels. These three services are not scams. They make a lot of money on the spread and interest and its to their advantage for you to make money and make more trades. Remember, when you make money, they hope its from other services and leads to more trades. I have other 1400 trades on the sites. I looked at my spread and commisions (FXCM has a commision for gold members, but ultra low spreads), it was over 30K last year. No wonder they like me. But my profit was over 500K. It039s not a scam and not impossible, but its a full time job for me. I spend 12 hrs per day 6 days per week studying. I read every paper in the world and spend hours on my charts. So ignore these fools. But treat it as a job and do your homework. If you treat it like Vegas, then you will lose just like Vegas. This is my career. No different than being an banker, doctor or lawyer. I get paid very well, but I have lots of stress, many sleepless nights trading the London market and days where I lose 10-20K. But the days I make 20-50K, they make up for it. From what I see, FX trading is very binary. Either you can do it or you can039t. So most either lose their money or make a ton of it. Luckily, I fall into the latter. I use the different sites for diversity and each does have something unique. My friends like Forex becasue it has the web platform and hand held platform. I like Oanda because it has unique trades such as trading Gold versus USD at 50:1 and also you can vary leverage for each trade. I really like FXCM becasue of the simple interface and the daily news and trade forum they have. FXCM has also now added a web platform. Its nice for trading on your vacation when you promised the wife to not trade and do it anyway on the hotel computer. I don039t have another job, but I could see it being useful for trading at work. I am definitely proof that they are not scams with my withdrawels. I remember reading this forum after I had made my first 200K using FXCM. The next day I took out 100K because I was paranoid. No problem, was in my account in three days. After I become a gold member with 10 Million in trades per month, the next wire xfer was one day. Gold members get preferred treatment. So if you want to trade forex, any of the three are great. I realize that not every site is legit. But I think you can trust the biggest outfits as they are making more money on the spread and don039t need to scam you. Maybe all of Wall St. is a scam, but these brokers are no different than Schwab or Merrill Lynch. You can lose your ss if you don039t be careful. I also like the interest rollover of Oanda and FXCM (I don039t know the Forex rules) versus some other brokers. FXCM charges or pays a simple interest per day the trade is open. Some brokers use a different system and it seems to penalize carry traders. But I am used to the Oanda and FXCM way, maybe the others are fine once you understand the way they do the rollover interest. D 7 years ago SCAM Don039t use this broker I Deposit 500 and when I wanted to withdraw them, the site showed a error. I contacted the LIVE support and the assistent didn039t even knew what to do. Finally I got help from another assistent, that sent me a link to another applicationform - but here I should provide them with informations, my bank didn039t even hat I am starting to think that all this Forex Trading, is one big scam, made by the gouverment to give us, normal people a falsh hope of making some money, but instead they rip us for even more then we have Alex 7 years ago SCAM Forex company stole my money. I was a customer of Forex company. One day i got a profit on currency trading. I took my profit and i was happy with that. But after 2 minutes all my profit disappeared and a very large loss appeared. First i did not understand how this can happened. I thought this is a software error and i restarted my trading platform. Nothing changes. Then i checked my trading history to see what happened. And i found three false bargains. I did not make those unprofitable bargains. I tried to ask Forex representative why they put three false bargains on my account. But he did not want to talk to me. So Forex company stole so much money from my account. Emmett digimode 7 years ago I have tested this company with close to a hundred demo accounts on the MT4 platform, using diferent names. I also tested forex with 5 live accounts for me and my friends so they have me in diferent names too. Let me tell you also that I tested about 30 other companies with demo accounts and about 3 other companies with live accounts. I found out that Forex stands out to be the best in both demo and live account. I never experienced any cheating in the live accounts, I had spikes that triggers my profit limits rather than stop loss. Another point I want to make about this company based on my experience with Forex market. The only demo account that emmulates live account nearly 100 is one that you open with Forex. You get as many requotes in demo account as in live account, there absolutely no diference between demo and live accounts, so after losing some money, I practice now exclusively with forex demo accounts. It is the only company I can recommend for anybody. contact me at forexbody(at)gmail if you like further confirmation. Andris 7 years ago This amazes me, how much people can whine about certain broker (not only forex), that this happened and that happened. Come on - just admit you are not a sucessful trader and thats that. Many of you dnt realise that it is NEVER EVER the same if you trade on demo and real money. It is where that 95 comes in - its in your head. I have been trading with them for 5 years now, and no, im not a big time shot making millions a month, im that guy with few thousand dollars to play with. Yes, there have been some problems with forex, both technical and peoples fault, and also my fault as well. So, here are the downers first, some are just my wishes, but nevertheless. 1. First-in first-out policy - i dont like that, but then again, it is now possible to close individual lots manually, but you cant put orders on those. 2. Support people are sometimes unaware of whats going on, and yes, for that alone it shoud deserve 1-2 stars at best. Then again, it depends, and you might get a helpful person on the other end of chatphone. 3. Spikes and lag during news, yes, sometimes 30-40 pips, but that goes for all brokers out there, and forex isnt the worst from which i have tried. 4. Difference between charts and prices given, sometimes 10 pips or more. Not very helpful for sharp scalping. 5. No hedging of positions. (tho i might be wrong about that) Probably there is more, but i cant remember on the spot. Now, the good: 1. The money depositingwithdrawing - never ever had a problem with that: wworks like a charm for me. Yes, it takes some time, but thats true for everything. Keep in mind, that a standart wire transfer takes 10 bank days to go through (2 weeks), checks can take 2 months, so if you are small time player, use getting back to credit card, if possible. 2. Unlike some others out there, they dont have that awful thing that you can put orders only 5-10 pips away from your position, can take even 1 pip if you like. 3. Their inside commentary, analysis, strategies are quite good. 4. Access through mobile phone - i use that alot to see whats going on, while not at computer. So, to underline all this - if you are new (i mean you have traded few months on demo), dont go for this, try to find some place where you can trade supermicro FX, and dont put all your money in there. To start with 250 is just rediculous, you are almost guaranteed to lose it. LEarn your ropes before you start, because as i said, its totally different psychology when you trade with real money. So go on, find a place where you can put 20-30 and play with 1cent a pip, and do that for at least 6 months before you go any further. If its not working - probably forex market is not the thing for you. Go trade stocks or play lottery or casino. Educate yourself, read books, maybe even go to some seminar or something. Forex is one of 3 platforms i use, and if i were not so paranoid about saying quotdont put all your eggs in one basketquot i would use that one alone. Last but not least - im not working for them, nor am i affiliated in any way, or paid to write reviews. Just a happy customer (most of the times:)). E. W. 7 years ago I039ve been successfully trading equities for seven years and decided to try currency trading. I opened my account in August after a cursory review of other sites. I admit, I was very nervous about it after reading all the reviews here. But, I have to say this site is very good I really like the trading platform. easy to use, clean and a good setup. This is DESPITE me having performed rather poorly in my first month of trading currencies. I understand there is a learning curve and I know I039m going to get better (my performance the last week of August has really turned around). The depositwithdrawal process is just fine and the live online support is great as well. Rajesh 7 years ago SCAM Except for one guy who says he made 500k (seems like a fishing story) everyone else has lost money. However, of the people that have lost money there seem to be two categories. There are those who lost and blame the broker and there are others who lost and blame themselves. I put 2500 into forex and traded for over six months and lost all of it. They promised me tighter spreads and charged me wider spreads, closed me out at the wrong time and pulled a few stop loss tricks as well. I thought I was duped but reading some of these posts I am beginning to think this is a real bucket shop. Regardless of the fact that we are bad Traders and whine after losing, I think there is more than enough unethical behaviour here to require an investigation. Has anyone tried reporting these guys to the NFA. Any luck with that approach. I have been using a practice account with Forex or Gain Capital for about 2 months now and I have never had a problem like stated above. A lot of time I think the customer does something or doesn039t understand something then just blame it on the company. This is especially true when the customer losses money. I say try the company out for the minimum deposit of 250. If you do not at least that much to lose, then you are in the wrong market. Daniel 7 years ago I use GAIN (Forex) with NinjaTrader. I have yet to have any issues with the company. Opening was easy, deposits were fast and data is reliable. I find it funny that all these posts talk about trades liquidated for quotno reason. quot Apparently, these people have very low account balances and shouldn039t be trading at all. I have never had a position liquidated, but perhaps that is because I have a large enough balance to cover the size of my trade. This company is definitely NOT a scam and it is sad that so many people mark them as a scam because they have no idea how to trade with high margin levels. If you labeled this company as a scam you either a) have so little money that any trade you make is vulnerable to volatility and they see that as a risk and liquidate b) have no idea how to trade with margin or c) are stpid enough to leverage your whole account on one trade. All of those deserve to have your position liquidated. I highly recommend either they NinjaTrader or MetaTrader platforms, as any real trader would recommend. I was very excited to see NinjaTrader teamed up with GAIN and you get a free copy of NinjaTrader. For all of those diots who think this is a scam: why would NinjaTrader (one of the MOST POPULAR trading platforms for real traders) team up with a company that is a scam They wouldn039t. You are retarded and shouldn039t be trading currency. Let me guess, you opened a futures account too and lost money because you leveraged your whole account on one contract Learn to trade. Great company, period. Pamela 7 years ago SCAM Total scam. Be very wary. I loved their demo account and had good success with it. When I went live with forex, everything changed. I suspect they are engaged in illicit activity. I was involved in an online forex school that highly recommended them. When live trading with them proved to be so impossible, compared with the demo, I began to feel that I had been set up. This is just speculation and may be way off base, but they definitely work hard to ensure that you do not profit. I don039t believe the reviews about making huge money with forex. I suspect the broker wrote those. I may be fairly new to forex, but I do pretty well at it, as long as I am very attentive. I am not simply a forex idiot who is blaming the broker for my failures. Something very strange happened while trading with this company. I would NEVER use them again and would never recommend them to anyone. Anthony 6 years ago I am a very frustrated customer of their MT4 UK accounts. Today, March 11, 2010, their system has been down all day. On top of that, they have been very unaccomadating and are unwilling to make any compensations or even waive swap fees. I do not and would not recommend this broker to anyone. VS 6 years ago Well, you should know that forex has a special aggrement with bank of america, which states that fors will provide BoA with the list of checks they authorize to cah out. So if you closed ur acct and Tradesatation send you a check, which is from Forex, that check maust be on the list. When u go to BoA they never can get hold of forex. So u end up running around and making calls to tradestation people, who also have no idea about that. I am having a check from forex, but Boa can not even accept it for deposit. it039s already more than a month. Maybe it makes more sense to pay them 25 and do the wire. Timur 6 years ago I have been with them for two years now. I can say they are not a scam. yes i have drained my account so many times being with them but now i am making money. No pain no gain :) I am not blaming them, because it it was due to my incompetence. I do not scalp with them. My strategy is medium term, so i do not give a shit about slippages and news. They are competent and have a good support team. There have been no problems withdrawing money from my account either. Conclusion: Those complain who can not trade. Cheers and good luck keith 6 years ago SCAM This company is a scam. I know exactly what I am doing in the market. i studied it for 3 years and I practiced it for several months on a demo account of theirs. I finally opened a new account with them and guess what 1. Their live server is dead slow making it impossible for u to make your moves on right entry and exit points. 2. They keep saying they are adding new servers. But it is a bull. You call their 800 number and the same guy who I was chatting on the live chat picks up. That is how small these people are. 3. I ask the guy Damon to give me the department who is in charge of technical assistance and he says he does not have any because they are internal numbers. They make the live servers slow so they can force you to lose your trades. I as an expert trader finding it difficult to trade with them. SO ALL THE NEW GUYS. PLEASE FIND ANOTHER BROKER AND HAPPY PIPPING jon 6 years ago woah woah woah keith, you039ve studied forex for three years and are a self-proclaimed master come on now, that just sounds ridiculous. Many traders go through many many many years of trading and do not call themselves experts. My personal experience with forex is not all that great. So far I039ve placed just over 1000 trades with them. I039ve only been trading 4x for 2 years and have live(account) with them for only over 8 months. I039ve tried fxcm039s micro crap, and though I039ve heard some people talk up there standard accounts, their micro platform just looks like a turd smearing my screen. I039m using the MT4 forex platform, I039m not a big fan of the spread, gbpjpy gets a little bonkers here and there, so i dont scalp it. I039ve been losing money to my own stupidity for the last 6 months, and it039s been a helluva great learning experience. it039s not like i put my life savings in here, and if you did, you shouldnt be trading, trade with money you don039t NEED to pay your rent with. Forex has not closed any of my trades. out of 1000 trades ive gotten 2 wrong contracts. (trying to play gbpjpy but got gpdchf or something like that) again, my fault, i should have 2x checked the trade. im only 23, and plan on continuing my learning experience for a loooong time. if you can039t take the pain, don039t play the game STARCRAFT 2 IS COMING OUT SOON SO QUIT FCKING CRYING AND GET READY TO RUUUUMMMMBBBLLLLLLEEEEE John Smith 6 years ago Hi, i am working with Forex for 2 years now. A few months ago i have decided to open a MT4 account with them. But i actually become a customer of and afiliate of them which is Gain Capital Forex. uk. After i started to trade and open another account for working through Zulutrade station they have send me a notice in wich they are anouncing me my boths accounts are terminated. The problem is that i am in DD position right now and they will profit from my loss as they are asking me to close all my open positions on monday morning or they will close them for me. Bellow i will show you the notice they have send it to me. I have to tell you that they didn039t phone me before that and ask me something that they found it unclear. They don039t care about customer and please stay out and run away as you can from this brokers because is so simple to let you open an account and then they will terminate that account without you being able to decide anything. Please look bellow what they are sending to me : Dear John Smith, Please accept this letter as formal notice regarding FOREX UK039s recent decision to close the above referenced FOREX UK account you hold with us and effectively terminate the customer agreement between your person and FOREX UK in full accordance with the agreement with such termination becoming effective as of the date of this letter. As a result of a recent review of your account activity, we determined we are no longer in a position to continue extending our services to you. As such, we have determined to close the account. Please note your account appears to have open positions and has a current remaining balance of 1730.36. You will have until 17:00 PM on July 12th to close your position. After which time we will automatically liquidate all open positions and terminate your account. To receive your funds, please complete, sign and submit the attached withdrawal request which is provided herein for your convenience Should you have any questions following this communication, please feel free in communicating directly to ComplianceForex. I thank you for your time. Thank you Kind Regards, David Fan Risk and Operations Manager GAIN Capital Vanessa 6 years ago SCAM These guys are pure scam. I had like 5000 in my account and I was trading 1 standard lot with a mental stop loss (because these guys WILL chase your stop loss if you put it there). My trade was going in the right direction, then the platform disconnected. It took me an hour later to get back in and guess what, they sold my position for 600 loss. That039s no freaking where near the margin, mind you. I bailed out ASAP. David Lonie 6 years ago SCAM Ho Boy. man. what the hell kind of site is this anyway. I was making a profit on a position and it still closed liquidated. below is an actual Live Chat with one of there Agent Brad right after this happened. Friday 4am to 5am October 15, 2010. enjoy for your reading pleasure. Beginning of Transmission Please wait for a site operator to respond. You are now chatting with 039Brad039 Brad: Hello david lonie, welcome to Client Services. May I have your email address to better assist you david lonie: email omitted Brad: Thank you for your information, how may I assist you david lonie: ok. this has happened to me repeatedly. my position which was up over 700 just vanished david lonie: granted a practice account039 david lonie: but i did not close the position. I was making money fake david lonie: so what gives Brad: I will look into this for you. Brad: One moment please. david lonie: i even had a Stop Loss and Limit set Brad: I do see this. david lonie: k. y did this happen Brad: After you increased your position, and then the market went against you slightly after the last trade, you feel below the margin requirement for this position and were liquidated. david lonie: that039s nonsensical. the margin should have been fine. a measly 96 would not have affected this. i was down over 2000 earlier which was way below margin and nothing happened only after i quotmanuallyquot ended the bleeding. your answer does not make sense. hence nonsensical david lonie: what else you got david lonie: this does not extend confidence in doing business with your firm david lonie: unless you can achieve some correctness to the platform. I am afraid I will have to close my Live account Brad: This is what happened in this case. Brad: One moment please. david lonie: and the case where i was going under in excess of 2000 well below margin with no liquidation But a closure with a positive revenue is justified as liquidation Make sense of this or I close my account. Brad: One moment please. Brad: The rate reached a high of 1.4114. At that time, the margin requirement for 900,000 lots would have been 25,440.86 david lonie: right and i was beating with the stream not against it. Brad: I do understand that. However, when you increased your position it put you close to liquidation. Once the market went against you a little you fell below the margin requirement. david lonie: my initial purchase price was around 1.4080 for 700,000 lots then I purchased another at around 1.40921 for 200,000 your 900,000, an avg. of 1.40857 approx.. still your margin argument is not making sense. david lonie: I was still ahead green david lonie: i was positive Not negative david lonie: if anything the last position should have been closed Not the whole position. that doesnt make sense. Brad: Whether you are in the positive or negative is not the issue here. david lonie: sure it is Brad: When you made the last trade it put you at risk. david lonie: if i am positive 16,000 lets say, my position is not going to close due to a lack of margin Brad: It can still close if you keep increasing your position. david lonie: the only risk was to the Forex practice pocket book. I will be closing my Live account. this is not the only site. eToro seems to be doing a much better job on their practice accounts. which usually translates to accurate and correct RealTime awareness Brad: I do apologize for this. However, it is your responsibility to maintain the margin requirement for your open positions. When you increased the position, you put yourself at risk for liquidation if the market went against you at that trade. david lonie: quotIfquot meant as under your meta-physical hunch Now, you are a prophet and fortune teller. sensationnel. Brad: Is there anything else I can assist you with david lonie: probably not Brad: Thank you for visiting. Should you have further questions or comments please log on to chat, email, call us at 1-877-FOREXGO (367-3946) or internationally at 1-908-731-0750. end of transmission So there you have it. I closed my account that day. Have not looked back. I was ahead kicking thier butt then they liquidated my account because quotifquot the market took a turn I would not be capable of a Stop Loss. I did graduate with a double major, one being Economics the other Financial Capital Mrkts. I am pretty sure I could handle a turn in the market. Here039s what happened to make me change my mind and start looking for a new broker: I 039Martingaled039 a position after very careful analysis. Btw 039Martingaling039 isn039t something I often do or recommend for beginners (or the faint of heart) and definitely don039t do it unless you have a large account AND you know EXACTLY what you039re doing as it can seriously bite you in the a. I was in a trade which had been losing money but had reversed and was shaping up to be VERY profitable. As insurance, I reduced my position (just in case I wasn039t correct) and the next thing I know my ENTIRE position was liquidated due to a separate order being placed by their system. AN ORDER WHICH I NEVER EXECUTED No stops were triggered WTF. What was about to be my all time most profitable trade ended up being a very sizeable loss for me. When I called them they said I must have done it What Why would I do that Basically they accepted zero responsibility and insinuated that I obviously don039t know what I am doing and I must have done it Unbelievable Btw as a side note, it turns out that my strategy proved to be 100 correct and I would have made an outstanding profit - thanks for nothing Forex Other issues I have had with them include - - Charts are sometimes slow when compared with other trading platforms. So what you think is happening ISN039T actually what IS happening - I observed this phenomenon most on their 5min chart (I have video evidence to prove this) - Issues with withdrawal requests e. g. they would just cancel a withdrawal request even though I had a large account and almost 100 margin available. Also delays in receiving my money e. g. they say 1-2 days but sometimes I have had to wait 4-7 days to receive my money. - Telling me my bank account details are incorrect when I triple checked them AND they are correct AND it039s the same bank account details they used to previously do my withdrawals. - On their website they say that as a non-US customer you can deposit funds into their bank account. This is when the fun begins On their site they list their bank account details. So I go online into my bank account and setup an online direct transfer to Forex and to make it easy I include my Forex trading account number as a reference for them. Then (and this happened EVERY time) they would email me after a day or two and say they don039t know where the funds came from. What I would then have to print off a statement and either fax or email it to them to 1) Prove it was my money to begin with. 2) Show it is my bank account Seriously let039s get into the 21st century already - I also had to get on their case and keep asking them to release their bonusincentive funds to my account even though I had more than met their trading requirements. To be fair there are a few plus points: I would get my money deposited into my account eventually, monthly interest paid on account balance was nice, decent enough 039Live Chat039, no withdrawal fees (due to my account size) and quite decent promotions from time to time. Anyway I think that039s enough and I039ve made my point. My tip, find a broker you feel you can trust - this is crucial to Forex trading success Forex trading is challenging enough without feeling like your broker could let you down at any moment. Good luck trading Max - Sydney 4 years ago SCAM Hi Guys, Thanks for this information, I039ve been playing with this market makers in Sydney for nearly 2 years and I lost 160k. I couldn039t believe this stories until I saw that they close my wining positions without my permission with excuse of reaching to the margin call, this bad, don039t waste your time and money with them. Aamir Saeed 3 years ago I lost 500 GBP with these criminals. They would close a position without any reason, Initially I deposited 250 GBP and added 250 again, they find one reason of the other and positions can be closed as fast as they open wiping out money from your account. On top of that, I didn039t even trade in forex, I was doing commodities. I have asked for return of my remaining 47 or so GBP and am still waiting. DO NOT waste your money with these guys. Dontbegypped 3 years ago With the understanding that they are counter party to your trade, one would keep an open mind for dealer plugins and such. I speak from a on amp off relationship with ForexUKUSUKUS, a Gain Capital division for the poor in monetary and big on dreams. News trading is far the worst, that if you held a position prior to it or just got unlucky, you can see all the delays in the price action keeping you humble. Yes, you could take advantage of this and they will honor it, but the negatives far outweigh the positive. The last despicable act came horror before my eyes. The EURUSD position I held changed to some other currency. No hot keys were pressed or accidentally scrolled. In fact, the journal was completely erased of any records even though no MT4 restarts either on or on VPS. Overall, a dealerbroker can delay, slip, disconnect, requote, or give show trade context busy etc, but changing one039s position was the final straw. At least, withdrawals and service is met with expectancy. Sanctimony 3 years ago SCAM I wouldn039t suggest the platform in general. The FTP platform is extremely sluggish and it is impossible to define defaults for market positions. The worst thing though is that they will arbitrarily close or change your position without your approval. This hovers on being borderline illegal. They will ignore a losing position and let you rack up losses, but quickly close a winning one. Their TOS probably has a hidden clause which allows them to tamper with your positions and close them at their own will, but I fail to see why anyone would continue to trade with this company once it happens to them. Would you continue trading stocks at a broker that suddenly sells off your entire holdings in a company because the stock surges upwards in price I think the analogy is fair and valid. This company is a fraud, plain and simple. I do conflict arbitrage on behalf of a Forex forum and at least 80 of the cases pertain to this site. I personally never traded here, but saw all the screenshots, video captures etc. myself, and talked to scammed customers on the phone. You should make physical records of your trading history with this company. Use a video feed if you have to. If they erase or close your positions without asking you in advance, take them to court. sam 3 years ago SCAM Its a scam. They are manipulating their software It seems that while you are trading, someone at the other end can speed up or slow down the software. They store your emotional pattern and play with it. Nasty business..I lost 5000. I dont regret it, charge to experience and donations to US govt. why they allow or not notice such scams. Huge Losses Forex 2 years ago SCAM First and foremost Forex makes up prices in there virtual environment, and they charge tremendous amounts of points. This is not real trades this is fake. DO NOT LISTEN TO POSITIVE REVIEWS AS I WAS TRICKED TOO. I lost over 3k I was upset then I started viewing MT4 on another site and was completely amazed by there 3 to 5 second price difference. Megan 9 months ago SCAM COMPLETE SCAM I made an account, deposited 2500 and started trading. I made a couple hundred dollars and requested to have it sent to my bank account for withdrawal. The time frame stated it could take up to 48 hours. It039s been over 7 week days. If I can039t even get that money out I039m probably not going to be able to get my 2500 back either. I thought I did my research before working with them but I guess not. I didn039t lose money on trades. I lost money because they wouldn039t give me earnings. Will be attempting to refund my initial deposit soon. George Harris 8 months ago SCAM I am having a continual problem withdrawing fund from my account. Gain Capital039s website states that it can take up to 2 business days to quotprocessquot your withdrawal. In reality, it takes them 5-7 days to return my funds. When I contact them to comlain, they blame my credit card company for the delays. Problem with that is I have a friend at my bank who is able to view the banks ledger and determine when funds hit my credit card. Turns put thae problem is Gain Capital. They dont like withdrawals so they delay processing them for up to a week befor releasing funds back to a credit card. Gain sends an email quotconfirmingquot my withdrawal request the same day I make the request. The funds are removed from my account within an hour by Gain, but they dont release them back to my card for 7-10 days. I wonder how much interest Gain is making off my quotfunds in limboquot that have bern removed from my account but not returned to me in a timely manner. Ambiguous 8 months ago I have read the comments about Forex and find the argument that Gain Capitals clients do not understand the risk rather funny and deceptive. I understand that risks are very prevalent in CFD039s, spot, or whatever you would like to call the contracts. There is one very big problem that I personally faced with Forex. The company suspended trading 3 consecutive times when they owed my own account. I approached the service department with these issues and was told that technical difficulties were the reason for the suspensions. Without honoring the orders placed while under suspension I was told that reduced spread would be offered for a short period of time. Now, to tell clients or potential clients that they do not understand risk is absurd. Clients of Gain must compete with slippage, rouge ticks, ect. Yet if clients do quotbeatquot the traditional and understood risks they can be stuck with a quotproductquot that is not exchangeable with a contracted service company who039s business is solely to make these exchanges. So, Gain Capital has one or more problems that can be identified as a scamunethical practice and please understand they will operate in this manner (I was a client for years). They have technology that is seemingly faulty when it does not benefit the company, they manually shut down (suspend) trades, or have routine liquidity problems to cover their own debts, ect. With Gain providing white label solutions for a variety of companies it would behoove of investorstraders to understand these issues are not isolated to forex and have been addressed, without resolve, to Gain Capital and their legal team. At best this is an unethical and immoral company. At worst they are the scam that so many have already labeled them
No comments:
Post a Comment